Smart browsers don’t download unneeded images

We ofter complain about browsers, browser inconsistencies, quirks, hickups, the list goes on. Let's say something nice to them, and hope for good karma 🙂

It happens as your web app grows in size and team members that some parts of the stylesheets become obsolete, no one remembers why they were there in the first place, but no one has cojones to remove them, because of fear that removing them might break something you forgot to take into consideration. Same case when you have the same stylesheet for 50 different pages and on some pages only some of the styles are actually used. I was wondering, do you pay performance penalty when you have style rules that refer to images, but the rules are never needed to render the page? Will the browser download all those unneeded images? The answer is No. The browser will try to avoid downloading the image assets as much as possible. And this behavior is pleasantly consistent across IE, FF, Safari (for Windows), Opera.

Test #1

I tried this stylesheet:

body {
    background: url(bg.png);
}
#some-id {
    background: url(ie.png);
}
.some-class-name {
    background: url(o.png);
}
p {
    background: url(image.php);
}

And applied it to a blank page that doesn't have any paragraphs, or elements with class name some-class-name, or ID some-id. The result was that only bg.png was downloaded, which is great.

> test #1

Test #2

I added a button which, when clicked, creates a new P element and sets a 3 seconds timeout before appending the new element to the body. (The background for the P element is the script image.php which only sleeps for 3 seconds for demonstration purposes, before redirecting to ff.png.) The result is that the image is requested only after the element is added to the document flow, not when it was created. Which is smart. It ain't added 'till it's added.

> test #2 (same file as test #1, btw)

Test #3

OK, modified test #2. A P element is created, its visibility is set to hidden and it's added to the document. It's officially in the document flow, although not currently displayed. My guess was that the browsers will download the image at this point. True for FF, IE7, Safari, Opera.

> test #3

Test #4

Here's the only inconsistence in the behavior of the browsers. A P element is created, but with display: none, then added to the document. So it's part of the DOM tree, but not really part of the document flow. Then another button changes display to block.

FF will wait for the display: block before downloading the image background
Opera will also wait until display: block
IE7 begins to crack under the pressure and downloads the image even with display: none
So is Safari

> test #4

So what?

Well, it's nice to know that the browsers won't download the images referred to from our stylesheets unless they are needed for rendering. There is a side effect though. If you happen to create dynamic elements that have some styles with background and no other similar elements already exists on the page, the user experience might suffer slightly as the image will generally be requested after the new element is added. In cases when this is important to you, you might need to take some extra care to make sure the image is downloaded before you add the new element. You might need to do for example a new Image() after initial page load. (reminds me of the good old days of image rollover buttons, those were the days, eh? Seems like no one does image rollover buttons and menus anymore. It's all css this, css that... 😉 )

Comments? Find me on BlueSky, Mastodon, LinkedIn, Threads, Twitter